If you’ve been following, I wrote a post a few months ago detailing five things that secretly take social workers out at the knees. Now it’s kind of a jerky move to write about all the ways your job might be lame without providing decent solutions. So last week I started in on the project of addressing each one. Find the first one here.
So…why do you say that I “hate” my clients again?! That’s strong language. Well, it has to do with walking on one of two life-paths. Continue reading “Why You May "Hate" Your Clients (Sort Of) And How To Get Off The Road of Suck”
Category: Uncategorized
How to Save Your Heart and Body in Child Welfare (1 of 5)
Last month I promised to address each of the five “secret” factors that take child protection workers out at the knees. You can go ahead and read that here. I call them “secret” reasons because they’re either not obvious to the public or because they represent beliefs that we covertly cling to.
Saving Your Body
Let’s talk about safety. Humans are pretty crappy at judging whether or not we’re safe. Maybe its fair to say that our internal danger-meters were calibrated in a different age. Yet just for fun, let’s test our safety knowledge. Which is more dangerous to a social worker:
- An angry, yelling dad enters your office demanding to see his baby son
- Driving to a meeting across town
Continue reading “How to Save Your Heart and Body in Child Welfare (1 of 5)”
Five Secret Reasons You Will Quit Child Protection in the Next 14 Months
I love social workers. I love their heart for the work. I love their drive and energy. I love how they take responsibility for problems they didn’t create. Social workers are awesome. Yet according to the stats, the average life expectancy of a child protection social worker is only 14 months.
You might be new to the field. Maybe you’re just finishing your degree or have a caseload of families for the first time ever. That’s exciting! I hope you do well and I wish you all the best. Can I share a couple of things? I don’t want to be a vocational buzz-kill, but there are some bumps coming down the road…hard bumps. I think you should know about them.
There’s the stuff we think about…the conscious stuff. But there are also other thoughts that creep just under the surface. Sometimes its the fact that the guy you’re with? He’s not a great long term idea. Probably need to move on. Buying a spanking new Jeep after graduation with a $600 per month payment? Yeah, maybe not the best decision making that’s now got you locked into payments for 36 months. Or 84. Ouch! It’s hard to see that in the moment. It’s the same in social work. There will be some realities that we may not want to be true. Parts of the work we secretly hate that lie just under the surface. Yet we may not be ready to hear those things. Maybe our new identity is wrapped up in social work. Maybe we just finished a four year degree and we’re paying off student loans. Maybe we just thought that THIS was the career for us. When we have those strong drives and motivations to stay in our field, the truth is often unsafe. So it sits there just under the surface. Waiting.
Like I said, I don’t want to mess up your social work mojo or anything. Yet I want to provide a couple guideposts for what may be lurking around in your cranium because at the end of the day knowing and accepting the truth of your experience is the best way to move forward in life. See if any of these secret thoughts and feelings fit your situation or put you at risk for running to the exit:
1) You know that you are not safe
Child protection work is dangerous. I remember racing through a house looking for a missing kid who I thought was hiding in some closet. The problem? Psychopathic dad might have been in the home hiding too. I remember my heart pounding as I went from bedroom to bedroom, quietly pondering the realization, “So this is how I die”. I remember running down the stairs and falling into a mess of police officers who thought I was Psycho Dad. Yikes!
So there’s the physically unsafe thing. That’s real. But that’s not even what I’m talking about. What I mean is that if you work in child protection, unless you are some emotional Adonis and impervious to psychological injury, you will likely sustain a wound in your soul that won’t heal anytime soon. Right now, 70% of all protection workers have at least one PTSD symptom and 15% are diagnosable. Half of PTSD victims will never shake their symptoms. Ever. If I told you that you had a 7.5% chance of losing your arm at this job, you might think twice about your line of work.
2) You secretly hate your clients
What? Sean, I think you’re projecting your crap on me, because I *love* my clients. Let’s explore this shall we? Don’t get me wrong- I care about many of my clients. I want the best for them. Yet I am also routinely subject to the following: I get sworn at, clients lie to my face, and after going above and beyond I routinely get no gratitude and in fact criticism for my efforts. I’ve also been spat on, physically attacked, lied about to my supervisor, and I’ve had things stolen from my office and my car.
On top of that are the things about my clients that I am forced to watch everyday. Abused and traumatized kids. Filthy hoarder houses. Dangerous neighborhoods. I get to sweetly maintain my unconditional positive regard while working with sex-offender dads who might be gratifying themselves with their own children. Yeah “hate” is a good word. Or maybe “profound grief and sadness” works a little better. Let’s just say “bad”. Really, really bad. Bearing witness to this level of human suffering and dysfunction (I’m not allowed to call it dysfunction though, because I’m “strengths-based”) takes its toll on our hearts. We need to acknowledge the honest disdain for the work that usually develops.
3) You have little power but sense that you’re fully responsible anyway
This is the curse of child protection! Through some crazy, twisted warping of reality, if a mom on your caseload decides to bring her 2 year old daughter to a crack shack on the weekend it is your fault. Really, you should have known better. Oh, but if you bring that little girl into foster care you’re a freaking cold-hearted monster who loves to break up families. You can’t win. This is what is classically known as a double-bind. Double-binds are awful on the psyche. Darned if you do, darned if you don’t. They suck so badly, in fact, that people once thought that being subject to a series of brutal double-binds as a child would lead to schizophrenia. This is also a special recipe for high stress. How do you stress a person out? Remove as many forms of control as possible from them and then make them morally culpable for an outcome they cannot possibly guard against. Fun times.
4) You actually became a social worker to fix yourself…and it’s not working
People fight me on this one…at first. It’s easy to deny. But let me tell you a secret. This is my area of doctoral research, and after the social workers who I interviewed realized that they were safe to talk, they all opened up. Of all of the research interviews I conducted, only one participant described her childhood as being free of abuse or neglect. Just one. The rest had endured beatings or sexual abuse from family, friends, and priests. Some were simply abandoned. A few were raised in crazy cults who trapped them. Some grew up “in the system”. But there’s more to this secret: what triggers them now in their work just happens to look EXACTLY like what they went through as kids. Also, what gives them the ultimately sense of meaning in their work is when they provide what just happens to look EXACTLY like the very thing THEY needed as kids. They couldn’t rescue themselves then, but they can spare their clients who are in similar circumstances. Their identification with certain clients just oozes out of them. And when their clients are not spared the same dire fate, they suffer in an especially cruel way. Many secretly hope that if they can sort out their client’s crap, their own crap will magically be sorted out too.
5) Your rescue fantasies have been based on a lie
I have another secret to tell you. We often don’t marry the people we marry. They’re impostors. But you’re an impostor too. What I mean is that the “love of your life” is someone we’ve fallen for, yet don’t even know. Oh we know a few things, like they’re an engineer or that they’re 5’11 or that they really dig us. But we don’t actually *know* them yet. And the way our brains work is like this: When we don’t know someone yet, our hopeful craniums take the liberty of filling in the blanks…with the best possible fantasies. Of course it doesn’t help that our beau-to-be is on his best behaviour too, and so are we.
Child protection is just like that. We learn in school about empathic responding and social justice and making a difference. If we just care about them and do “consciousness raising” with our imaginary too-be clients they will magically “get it” and blossom before our eyes like the clients do on Judging Amy (yes, I’m old). And that’s if you come from the middle class. If you come from crazy-nutso homes or grew up in the system, I know that you know better (but in that case you had better camp out on Number 4).
No, unfortunately our hopes for who our clients are, the effect we can have in their lives, and their capacity to change has been grossly overestimated. It’s what we thought would complete us, but it doesn’t.
So…thanks a bunch Sean for that lovely blog post that has graced my smart phone. Truly, you have inspired me! Okay, so…I am sorry. I didn’t want to burst your bubble. I would love to write posts about pink fluffy unicorns dancing on rainbows. But this is pain with a purpose. I mean, if we don’t acknowledge the sucky, crappy parts about being social workers, how can we get stronger? How can we move on? We cannot change what we will not admit to be true.
So in the spirit of everything that is good, right, and happy, here is my plan. Every week for the next five weeks I will write one short blog post to address each of the the above five secret reasons to quit. I don’t really want you to quit, but I am also sick of seeing you get hurt. I promise to help you find solutions to each of these problems, deal?
Maybe there’s something that wasn’t on this list that you think should be. Let me know in the comments section and let’s talk about it.
Rest is Not the Absence of Something
A clear sign of workplace burnout is this: the dividing boundary between one’s downtime and one’s responsibilities can get really blurry. This might look like doing work stuff at home and home stuff at work. Oftentimes I have spoken to helping professionals who find themselves surfing Facebook at their desk, even (especially?) when there is a stack of paperwork to get done. They are often the same people who will pick up calls from clients on the weekend, when clients should be the LAST thing on their mind. Do you see the boundary breakdown here?
This happens because over the years something inside us has fallen into disarray; perhaps the executive part of our brain that governs planned behavior has been chronically overwhelmed by the excessive demands of life. Our discipline may have therefore eroded to the point where we lack the internal fortitude to deal with anything other than what happens to be in front of us.
Any of us who have worked in social services (or who are parents, which is just another form of social service) for any length of time have realized that the work never ends. I remember hearing about a man who dedicated 40 years of his life to child protection. He made a greater impact than most during his sometimes grueling years of service. Yet mere months after his retirement party few remembered him. The work existed long before him and now continues to exist in his absence. The clients will never stop calling. The laundry will never be finished. It like chasing after the wind.
The same is true for you. You will not get to the bottom of the pile. Ever.
So knowing that the pile is eternal, why do you put off rest? Why do you treat downtime as though it is a prize that can only be earned once “finished”? It will never be finished. Now in our defense, we didn’t grow up this way. Most of us “finished” each school year at the end of June and were once able to savor an annually-held endless summer with our friends. Later on at college, we knew that if we just persisted past our finals we could drive home and enjoy a month of Christmas on our parents’ dime. Back then, it made sense to incentivize rest because the nature of our work was finite.
Not so now. Now we play the long game. The training runs and 5k races have past and we are now competing in the ultra-marathon. So let me state this clearly: rest must be prioritized as a “To Do” item, not as the absence of something. It does not have to be earned. You never have to be worthy of it. You never have to justify it. You just take it because if you don’t it will never happen on its own.
My partner struggles with guilt at the thought of rest. She’s a very productive and devoted mother of three who is also running a household, upgrading her education, working part-time, and preparing to launch a business. It feels hard for her to justify rest because in the moment so many other things- the kid’s school assignments, prepping for work, and managing the general chaos of motherhood- seem far more urgent and important. Mostly she just feels a powerful sense of guilt at the thought of taking time for herself.
But one day we discovered an interesting trick for how she could justify getting a couple of days away, minus the mental guilt trip. She planned a getaway at a scrapbooking retreat. The idea is that she could spend a weekend away with friends in her PJ’s while “working” to produce an album or two of family memories. Within that framework she found the permission needed to totally relax, unwind, and most importantly avoid the emotions of shame and guilt at the thought of leaving her family behind.
Also, this period of rest did not look like a blank spot in her daytimer. There was a large block covering Friday, Saturday, and Sunday called “Scrapbooking Retreat”. Having that time scheduled in made it real and protected the time from the nagging list of other things that could invade it.
That said, rest periods needn’t be a weekend long. Even a regular hour dedicated to one’s own needs, plotted in pen, and fiercely guarded can be the salve our hearts and minds need to recover.
So what about you? Do you schedule your rest time? I would recommend that you not only write it down, but that you describe the activity as something more specific than “rest”. If your vision is to go kayaking that day, then write that down. Maybe it’s just an hour one evening for a bath. Write that in! The concreteness of it will help you resist the temptation to let other things take priority.
For us, the work will never stop. Therefore we must reorient our perspective from “finish line” focus to “journey” focus. If we can do that, maybe we will find the rewards we seek along the way.
Becoming an Inner-Child Protection Worker
The longer I work with children and families, the more this conviction strengthens within me: we all need a mom and a dad. Period. Now, before you accuse me of trying to sell you on the traditional two-parent, heterosexual family as a panacea to all that ails our society hear me out. What I mean is that there needs to be a grown up in a child’s life who embodies the classic traits of “mom”. You know- your biggest fan. Your unconditionally loving nurturer. The one who sees your side. Maybe the only one who loves your face.
You also need a “dad”. Someone who pushes you. Someone who steers the ship. Someone who’s strength you can depend on when you are weak. The one who teaches you how to stand on your own two feet and get up when a bully knocks you down.
Of course these are ideals that only find their perfected forms in our imagination. In reality, my parents were often anything but that rosy picture. They were tired, mostly, and like the rest of us, deeply flawed in their own way. As goes the cliche, I am at a place now where I am profoundly able to withhold judgement for their failings because I have sired a brood of my own and have fallen far short. Parenting is simply hard work, and none of us can be the total parental package.
But here’s where I am going: I never realized that in addition to raising my own children, I would also be called to parent myself.
As adults we have to become mom and dad for ourselves.
With that thought in mind and before you accuse me of getting all woo woo on you, let’s consider what self-parenting may look like.
Who is the internal mother?
As above, she embodies grace and compassion. She is the one who knows your true worth, even when others may miss it. She is responsible for your care on all levels. She is the one who makes you eat a sandwich when you feel like you have no time to even breathe. She is the one who remembers that you are crazy about gerber daisies and puts them on your desk. She is the one who holds you tight when someone breaks your heart. Most importantly, she never leaves.
Let’s turn the tables. Do you have her on board? In other words, have you learned to care for and nurture your own heart and soul as our iconic mother would? A good way to take stock is to ask, “Do I give myself a break when I fail at something?” or “Do I combat the malicious voices that tell me I am worthless or stupid?”
For some of us, we had mothers who were harsh or cold. Sometimes we carry those mothers with us into adulthood and it holds us back. It makes our internal space an unsafe environment. I am reminded of an experiment where researchers asked women what they thought of their bodies and most had horrific things to say. They said things about themselves that they would never say to another human. Some of us carry this harsh internal voice everywhere we go. The good news is that as a grown adult, YOU get to choose your own mother. That is, you have the power to practice self-compassion and unconditional self-love because you are in charge of what goes on inside your noodle.
What about the internal father?
Just like the idealized depiction above, dad is strong and smart and capable. Dad isn’t better than mom, just totally different. He is the one who puts his foot down when you’re being irrational. He is the one who let’s you do crazy unsafe stuff just to prove to yourself that you can. He is the one who teaches you to stand up to the bully after mom has hugged away the hurt. You see, mom and dad are a perfect team together.
When it comes to paternal dysfunction in our real lives, many of us suffered either from overbearing and violent fathers, or simply dads who weren’t there. Harsh and micromanaging fathers may have produced a strong sense of rebellion in us as we struggled to escape their irrational grip. Conversely, some of us are processing the grief of having had absent fathers. They left us with a great chasm in our hearts that we may still long to fill. Many of us entered adulthood insecure and directionless, with little sense of ourselves because we simply didn’t have a father to help us test our mettle.
What does your “on-board father” look like? Ask, “Do I rebel or quit when life gets tough or my boss challenges me?” If your dad was absent ask, “Do I go from thing to thing to thing, or from lover to lover to lover searching for someone to fill that void in me?”
Thankfully, as a grownup YOU get to choose your father. You get to choose the voice who encourages you to push farther and fight harder and test your own limits.
I have learned that as a social worker, I need to cultivate the crucial skills necessary to parent myself. In order to stave off burnout and disillusionment, I need to mother myself. I need to care deeply for myself. I need to protect myself and my heart from the haters, including the ones within. At the same time, to prevent wallowing in despair and avoidance, I need to father myself. I need to admonish myself to face my fears, to pick up the phone and face that scary client. I need to push myself to keep learning my trade, to not get too comfortable in my union position, and to not become complacent.
If you are a helping professional, I would gently invite you to ask yourself, “Have I been meeting my own needs, primarily?” That is, have you provided that “secure base” for yourself from which you may confidently act?
I have watched many child protection workers strive and claw and clamor to protect the little bodies and hearts of the kids on their caseload, and yet they suffer tremendously on a personal level. Before we can truly help others in a sustainable way, we must become our own inner-child protection workers.
Many Social Workers will Hate Me for this One… (Drop the Myth of Work-Life Balance and Save Your Sanity- Part-6)
We’ve come to the end of my series on reducing your sense of overwhelm and stress at work and I have saved the best for last. I debated sharing this one action that, if taken, will lower your helping professional stress-load more than anything else. I know that your job is crazy. I know that some days you feel like trading your briefcase in and selling hot dogs on a street corner. But I’m warning you that the final action step I’m about to talk about slays a pretty big sacred cow and I expect to get some unkind emails about it. However before I share what it is, let’s recap what we’ve learned over the past five posts (if you want to just get on with it, by all means scroll down).
In the first post of this series (which can be found here), I argued that the notion of ‘work-life’ balance is only a myth that causes us a good deal of grief. I suggested that we can only do one thing at a time and that we get into trouble when we try to multitask. Feelings of overwhelm (leading to procrastination, compulsions, and feelings of hopelessness) often follow when we unsuccessfully try to achieve the imaginary state of “balance”.
I then promised to offer five solid actions, that if taken, would guarantee your feelings of overwhelm would diminish and be replaced by greater productivity and a heightened sense of subjective well-being. That’s a big promise! But I’m just curious- have you tried any of them yet? After all, knowledge adds little if one does not learn to execute. It’s like reading diet book after diet book, expecting that simply pouring over those pages will melt the pounds away. Okay, I’ll get off your back for now… Let’s recap what we’ve covered:
Action Step 1: Get it all out of your head and down on paper. You can find that post here. Write down every little job, idea, appointment, grocery item, emotion, wish, project, and “to-do” item that has been clogging up your precious noggin. After everything is down (it may be hundreds of items!) develop a master action list. Also, if you are an “idea” person, I would recommend keeping a journal close by for you to store all of those brilliant (and often distracting) thoughts. Once you have a prioritized list, start knocking them off one by one.
Action Step 2: Park passion and pursue performance. That post is here. This is primarily a mind-shift, but it leads to a completely different set of actions. When we release the self-focused idea that we should be “living our dreams” or “following our bliss” and instead adopt a mentality that is focused on enhancing our productive powers in the service of others, the result is a calm but powerful impact on the world. True bliss follows from this.
Case in point: when I started a new position years back (even though it was a clinical counselling job that I had been dreaming about having for more than a decade) I quickly became dissatisfied. I started searching the online job ads EVERY DAY for a year and a half. I became obsessed with finding the actual job that would satisfy my every desire. What if instead of that, I invested those 15-20 daily minutes into finishing my Ph.D., or into a weight training routine, or writing love letters to my wife, or in prayer and meditation? What could have been different in my life if I had spent those 182 hours (or 5 weeks of full-time work) producing value instead of fruitlessly longing for something else? If you’re looking for a specific actionable step, try this: write down one thing you want to get really good at while at your present job. Create a list of the steps you would need to take over the next 6-12 months (including what resources to tap, who you can ask to mentor you, etc.) to make this happen.
Action Step 3- Systematize your work-life. Find it here. For a busy professional, systems are salvation. We require systems that allow us to free up our mental and emotional space for other things. Setting up your working life in a deliberate way is a bit of up front labour, I won’t lie. However, the more you learn to rely on habits and routines (aka: autopilot) instead of willpower to get your work done, the less of an emotional and psychological toll your work will exact on you. There are many work hacks specific to the helping professions that will save you a good deal of grief.
Action Step 4- Build good boundaries. That post is here. I would say that about 2% of people went into the helping professions because they wanted to make money or enjoy fame and prestige, or because it’s “just a job to pay the bills”. If I wanted a job that was solely about income I would have become an investment banker (sorry, investment bankers!). No, we got into the field because of a flame inside of us, large or small, that was stoked whenever we offered help to another human being. I would suspect that many of us (especially those of us in child protection or other “hardcore” helping jobs) also wanted to do something that mattered. We wanted to stand in the gap and make a difference.
The trouble is that what fuels that passion can also be recipe for poor boundaries. In turn, poor boundaries burn us out with a capital “B”. The number one issue I see is when social workers, counsellors, etc., start taking responsibility for items that belong solely to their clients. If you struggle with boundaries, I recommend sitting down and thinking about what you are and are not responsible for in your present position, and then vigorously defend your line.
Okay now that we’ve reviewed, let’s ready the sacred cow!
As I mentioned above, I would reckon that you are defined by your big heart. You are willing to crawl into the trenches and get dirty for your clients. It just seems like the right thing to do. Remember, we are talking about reducing feelings of overwhelm. Reducing burnout. Keeping you in the game. World War I was a war of attrition and the men who fought overseas experienced real physical trenches. Many of those who survived came home shell-shocked; they were forever changed. Many knew they would die in those trenches and were prepared to pay that price. What most didn’t know, however, was that if they survived, their lives would never be the same. Simply being in the trench harmed them, even if they never took a bullet. Why? Because they watched their friends take bullets for them. And for every one terrifying thing they watched with their own eyes on the battlefield, they heard the stories of ten or twenty more they didn’t see.
Now, how do I say this? How do I convey this concept without sounding cold-hearted or cynical? Allow me to just come out and say it. If you want to survive in a helping field like social work, there is one thing you need to do- one thing that will protect you:
You have to stop caring with your emotions. You must remove your emotional presence from the horrific things you hear about.
I know that this is a tricky concept, so let me try to explain myself.
I am not saying you shouldn’t care, period. What I am saying is that you have to learn to care in a way that is sustainable.
Let’s look at this logically. Think about cognitive-behavioural therapy. We know that it isn’t the thing that happened that makes us upset- it’s the way we think about the thing that happened. We know that sometimes people have misbeliefs that cause them to experience unnecessary grief. We all know that if we ruminate on catastrophic thoughts (like maybe my husband will die or maybe my child will be kidnapped or maybe I will be diagnosed with terminal cancer) that our mental and emotional state can take a nose dive pretty quick. And that’s all imaginary!
Or perhaps we hear that our brother fell off the roof and broke his leg or that our daughter is getting a divorce. Even though these things aren’t happening directly to us, we are devastated because of the strong bonds we have. We naturally take on their emotions and grieve with them. This is totally normal and makes us human.
Yet helping professionals step into those traumatic stories all the time, all day long. If you are like most of your big-hearted peers, it means that you will be naturally inclined to stand closely with your clients. You’re compelled to deeply empathize with them and support them; to feel what they are feeling as though they were your family.
What makes this a problem is that the human heart can only withstand so much of this before it begins to truly suffer- this is what some have called vicarious trauma and secondary traumatic stress. I have argued in the past that experiencing this trauma puts us on the road to burnout quickly. That’s why the average lifespan of a child protection worker is only 14 months.
So when I say, “stop caring with your emotions” I mean just that. You may already notice that most seasoned older workers do this anyway. They say and do the right things and are very professional. They communicate authentic empathy to clients. Yet upon further examination you may observe a certain subtle detachment about them. If you watch closely, you can see that things don’t land very hard on them. They don’t think about their young client who was sexually assaulted when they go home at night. In fact, they rarely dwell on those things. Yes, they meet his needs at work. They act with compassion and understanding. But they disavow the weight of what has occurred.
You may be asking, “Ok, Mr. Smart Guy, just how am I supposed to do that? Turn off my heart? Not care? Yeah right!” I want you to know that I hear you and I don’t have any easy answers or turnkey solutions. What I can say is this: in high-trauma professions like social work, this dynamic takes out more good people than anything else. The really scary part? If you do acquire full-blown secondary traumatic stress, the recovery rate is only 50%. Those aren’t good odds.
I promise to go into much more detail about the steps you can take to protect yourself from vicarious trauma and secondary traumatic stress in future posts. But for now, think about how counsellors extinguished phobias in clients- through graduated exposure therapy. When you get thrown into a scary job, there’s nothing gradual about it- just a lot of exposure! Eventually, however, as you learn that you are personally safe from harm and that your extreme emotions are not needed, those heavy feelings begin to subside.
Think about becoming a skydiving instructor versus skydiving the first time. The very first time you jump out of a plane, what are you thinking? “I am going to die!!” Why would you think that? Because you should die! Jumping out of planes is not normal. Yet after many, many jumps, the fear disappears. Why? Because in spite of your actions, you remain unharmed over time. Your brain knows this and therefore doesn’t need to flood itself with fight or flight hormones. By the time you’re teaching others to jump out of planes it’s an emotional piece of cake.
Eventually, you will be able to think and talk professionally about the horrific things you see and hear without carrying the emotional weight of those things. That is the nature of disavowal. It’s like any other icky job you can’t avoid doing like changing dirty diapers or taking out the compost bucket. You learn to dissociate from the disgust of it, while still getting the job done.
One final caveat. This is not the same as what can happen to those who have undergone extreme trauma. Victor Frankl described the experience of people completely shutting down emotionally while in concentration camps after undergoing unspeakable suffering. In that case, their entire emotional centers collapsed in an attempt to cope with their extreme condition. This is something qualitatively different. In our case we are talking about ways that we can preserve our hearts while at work so that we can be emotionally available for our friends and family when we get home.
When you learn this vital skill, you will be better protected from the scourge of repetitive stress injuries- not of your hands or legs, but of your heart. And the state of your heart is all that matters to me.
That’s the end of this series, but stay tuned- there’s more to come.
Wishing you all the best.
Heal Thy Boundaries (Drop the Myth of Work-Life Balance and Save Your Sanity- Part 5)
As someone who has worked for the past decade in front line social work, I have seen a lot of crazy stuff. I have witnessed boat-loads of grief. I have heard tales of trauma and deep sadness and absolute terror that would make your skin crawl. I’m sure many of you can relate. Working in direct practice with clients can be really hard. Yet the thing that nags at me the most is this:
I hate watching social workers turn themselves into emotional pretzels because they can’t see where they end and the client begins.
Does that sound harsh? Please let me explain myself.
A few weeks ago I promised to lay out a few practices that, if taken, would ensure a reduction in your subjective sense of overwhelm and an increase in workplace serenity. My motivation is that I want you to feel better and I want you to stay in the game. One of the most significant stressors I have witnessed is a tendency by dedicated, good-hearted helping pros to become emotionally over-involved with the people they serve. Now, we can expect that when you get to know a family you will become attached. That’s a pretty human process and I don’t want you to feel bad about that.
Trouble comes when we subtly cross an emotional line of responsibility. Here’s what I mean: if you are a child protection worker and a child on your caseload experiences harm in some way, whose fault is it? Assuming you did what you could based on what you knew in line with the mandate of your position, it is categorically NOT YOUR FAULT. If you’re a crisis line counselor and you get a call from a depressed person, perhaps you try your absolute hardest to respond to that caller compassionately and with deep empathy. The call ends when they tell you that you just don’t understand them (or something meaner) and they hang up on you. Is that your fault? IT IS NOT YOUR FAULT.
And yet we can feel the pressing guilt of failure, as though we caused their abuse or we caused their depression.
I frequently have workers confide in me that when things go wrong on their caseload they feel personally responsible. I have watched countless social workers burn out, quit, or simply endure significant suffering because they truly believe that on some level they were responsible for their client’s grief or they could have done more.
If you can relate to this, please be gentle with yourself. You probably come by it honestly. What I mean is that as a helping professional I am willing to bet that you were called to this career because of vivid formative experiences. Perhaps you “became the emotional parent” for your younger siblings or even for your mom when you were a kid. Maybe you simply found that your classmates in high school regularly confided in you and it felt really good. There is no shame in any of this. What we need to keep in mind, however, is that we may also carry longstanding misbeliefs into our professions that can reek emotional havoc on our hearts in the here-and-now.
Boundaries 101
What is a boundary? It is where you end and another person begins. Let’s look at some more obvious ones. I can’t take off my coworker’s shoe. Why? It’s her shoe and her foot, not mine. I have my own shoe. I can’t expect my friend to pay my cell phone bill. That’s my bill, not his. It is my responsibility.
Boundaries become a little trickier when children are involved. For instance, if your two year old runs across the street and gets hurt, who’s responsible? I’m afraid it’s you. Entirely you. The reason is that the little guy is only two and you are fully responsible for his safety. Now fast-forward 20 years. If your 22 year old runs across the street and gets hurt, who’s responsible? Is it you? In NO WAY is it you. Why? Because now your little guy is a grownup and is completely responsible for himself.
Our boundary relationships develop more or less instinctively. For example, if you saw someone else’s two year old bolt out onto the street, you may jump in AS THOUGH you were their parent. You’re not actually responsible, but it just feels like you should be. The same happens with our clients. We watch them live their lives at a range of capacities. Sometimes, those capacities are marginal at best.
The result is that we may unconsciously become the “parent” in a parent-child type relationship.
And if you are the parent in a parent-child relationship, guess what- in your head and heart you’re responsible! Let’s take this a little further. If you are responsible as an actual parent to your clients then what of your lunch break? No, parents don’t get lunch breaks. What about leaving at 5pm? No, parents don’t get to leave their job at 5pm. What about suffering verbal abuse from your client? No, parents have to just take it (actually, if your client was really your young child, you would be granted the power to step in and train that child so that they stop verbally abusing you. But they are only your client, remember?).
What I am saying is that it is so easy to find ourselves in an emotional quagmire of messed up roles and boundaries. This, in turn, is a recipe for compulsive work behaviours, feelings of overwhelm, and eventually emotional burnout. The hard fact is that if you think that this applies to you, it’s actually your job to correct it. You need to sort yourself out and perhaps re-establish healthy boundary lines.
If you are feeling overwhelmed about where to begin with repairing your boundaries, here is a simple plan of action that I have plucked from my Recover Your Resilience course that I think could be a good start in terms of rethinking your practice:
Discerning process from outcome.
As a helping professional, you get paid for process, or what I call “process commitments”. You are paid to show up, to work with your client population, to think about them, to strategize with them, to partner with them to achieve goals, and to hopefully be an agent of change in their lives. Of course you are invested. You desire great outcomes. This is why you got into your field- you want to help people to recover/heal/grow/get better. However, you are not ultimately responsible for the decisions of your clients. You owe a duty of care to them and you may even hold a statutory office, such as a legal mandate to protect children on your caseload. Those are significant responsibilities, to be sure. Yet at the end of the day, 99% of the time you are really not responsible for your clients’ ultimate outcomes (There are a few exceptions, such as if you are directly caring for a child or someone with an intellectual disability and hold direct responsibility. Even then, we may take on extra guilt that is not ours to endure).
When meeting with your supervisor or with clients it is important to get straight what your goals are. I never begin working with a client until I am clear with myself, my client, my supervisor, the referring social worker, or the agency, in writing, what the goals are. Having the goals put in writing and signed by all parties allows you to defend yourself later if needed (The good news is that many agencies already have these goal-based systems in place). Remember that if an item or goal in the contract is listed as an outcome, it should only have the client’s name attached to it. If it is a matter of process it can also have your name attached (if you have truly agreed to it).
Here are some examples of desired Outcomes:
- Client will maintain sobriety
- Client family lowers risk factor X
- Client’s global assessment of functioning goes from 17 to above 40.
- Client will return to work by the end of March
Here are some examples of process commitments:
- Client will attend all scheduled appointments
- Therapist will liaise with school to discuss support options
- Client will enroll and attend Positive Parenting Program
- Social Worker will schedule one hour per week with client
Notice that only the client is responsible for outcomes but either client or worker can be responsible for process commitments. So then, you can be held responsible for, say, not calling the Drug and Alcohol Rehab Centre as agreed upon to see about enrollment for your client. That does not make you responsible for your client’s commitment to sobriety, however.
When clients feel the negative effects of their choices, it makes sense that they will sometimes look for other places to place blame. Actually most of us do this- it is a way to preserve our sense of self or dignity in the face of failure. It can therefore be a frequent occurrence when a child is apprehended from a home for a parent to say “This is your fault! You didn’t meet with me enough!” or “I didn’t know that X was your bottom line- you didn’t tell me!”
I know that this section may come across as somewhat adversarial or “lawyer-ish”. In other words, it sounds as though it assumes the worst about people- that our clients will be manipulative, that our bosses will blame us, that we will have to fight for our vocational lives in an unsafe system. The sad fact is that to some degree this is true. Hurt people hurt people. Dysfunction and its consequences are central to our profession. However, the primary reason for having goals and expectations set out in writing, every time, is to actually facilitate functional, trusting relationships. Fences exist between neighbors to keep pets and shrubs on the right side and mark out everyone’s territory. That does not assume animosity between those neighbors, but instead it lays a groundwork for a fair and mutually beneficial relationship.
How are your boundaries? What lines have been crossed in your life by your family members, clients, or friends? Let us know in the comments section below.
Zen And The Art of Paperwork (Drop the Myth of ‘Work-Life’ Balance and Save Your Sanity- Part 4)
When I was the tender age of 18 I traveled up north to try my hand at tree planting. Let me paint a picture for you- it is grueling, sweaty work. The job basically consists of slogging a large bag of baby trees up and down a mountainside, stumbling around to find suitable “micro-sites” on which to plant each sapling, digging a little hole and and planting them one by one. We would work from 6am until about 5pm, have dinner and then go straight back to our tents to recoup before the next day’s grind. I remember working 13 hours the first day and planting less than 100 trees. At $0.12/tree, minus $25 per day camp fees, that meant that after an impossibly hard day I earned about negative $13 dollars!
While toiling along, I noticed another guy who looked sort of like a Buddhist tree-planting monk. I would watch him float up and down the mountainside planting trees. He never seemed to sweat. He was always in a good mood. His work looked…..well, not like work. Even though he seemed to be expending almost no calories, he commonly planted 2000+ trees per day! I remember staring quizzically at his serene countenance one day, pondering his magical secret.
I eventually asked him to reveal his secret, to which he replied, “I have practiced these skills for so long that I don’t even think about the work anymore. My body moves along, and my mind is mostly somewhere else.” Since then, I have marveled in a similar fashion when watching veteran social workers and counselors serenely go about their days, apparently unbothered by the demands of their work.
Now, after obsessively interviewing these long-surviving front line workers, I have gleaned many insights which I plan to share with you in the coming months. These veteran helping professionals consciously or unconsciously do many specific things that not only keep them in the game, but keep them relatively at peace as well. But for today, I want to share about one little-talked-about attribute shared by most highly successful helping pros: they have developed and use systems for managing their work-lives.
They do not rely on their minds to do the heavy lifting their job requires. Here four basic tools effective professionals use:
- A day planner
- A to-do list
- A daily, weekly, and monthly routine
- A personal filing cabinet
Let’s quickly go through these one by one. If you have no tolerance this morning for technical “shop talk” you can just skim them. But fair warning- I’m going to geek out a bit on these.
1. The day planner
I know that this should seem obvious, but you would be surprised how many social workers don’t use their planners to their full potential. If, like me, you are required to report what you do- the phone calls you make, whether the client showed up or not, etc- then the day planner is not just about remembering future events, but keeping a running log as well. For example, I am required to electronically log every call I make to a client, every text, every meeting. At the end of the month, those stats are passed up the chain to the program funder to ensure my agency is meeting it’s deliverables. When I first started out, I would get to the end of the month and then have to piece together who called me. It meant going into my phone’s call display, looking in client folders for notes, going into my work cell phone for texts. It was a nightmare!
Now my day planner never leaves my side. Every time, I get a text from a client I write a shorthand note about it corresponding to the line for whatever this moment’s date and time is. This practice drove me nuts in the past because I perceived it as tedious, but now I see the light. Now it is pure zen. I am just the tree planter floating along. When month’s end comes, it’s all there. No crazy searching.
I also write case notes in my planner (I have a big 8 X11 one with one day per page). The notes go right beside the scheduled appointment entry. This forces me to be economical with my words and get to the point.
2. The to-do list
I keep two lists, actually: one for the realm of work tasks, and one for home tasks. Do you know where I store those lists? In my day planner! The home list is there because throughout the day, items from my home-life just come up, and the list allows me to put the item out of my head until the end of the day. My practice is also to order work tasks from hardest to easiest, and tackle the hardest one first. These tend to be fairly short lists because of the next system. I learned that my Buddhist tree-planting friend had a similar structure. For example, he always kept every tool he used in the exact same place. He always did every step in the exact same order. This made the process mindless for him. A to-do list similarly frees your mind for other things, while ensuring meet your professional obligations.
3. The daily, weekly, and monthly routine
Routines are prescribed and deliberate actions that effectively remove the need for willpower. Routines are a procrastination killer. Conversely, a lack of routine feeds procrastination. Have you ever kept putting off that report until the deadline and then stayed late to get it done the night before? Not only is that extremely stressful, but it causes ongoing anxiety the entire time you’re avoiding the job. I have learned (though I’m not perfect at it) to schedule my common work tasks and then stick to that schedule. For instance, we have just seen how my custom is to enter every step I make into my day timer as I go along. My habit for writing my notes is that I write them in my car after each client session. I enter my mileage and expense receipts at the end of every day without fail.
I also answer almost every email the moment I read it if I can. You should only have to deal with an item ONCE. Not multiple times. I batch enter my notes onto the electronic case management system once per week. I typically do this on Thursday mornings. By performing these tasks on a schedule, I reduce the randomness of my job thereby reducing my stress levels. That way, when things go sideways (as is normal in the world of child protection) I can respond from a place of strength rather than a scattered place.
4. The personal filing system.
This may be the biggest time saver I have. Unfortunately, my world is still one filled with all manner of paper-based reports, notes, and records. I just don’t have the mental energy to handle large, unmanageable piles. So I have developed a two-drawer filing system comprised of just a few crucial folders. The bottom drawer contains all of my case files. Not the agency case files, mind you- just a single, thin file folder for each client containing their referral document, my latest report, and only the most crucial documents.
In the upper drawer I have only a few folders: one containing many copies of all of my intake docs, one with copies of commonly used referral forms, and one that contains the various flyers and print outs for social service resources that come across my desk from time to time. Aside from that, I have a small “inbox tray” on my desk that I empty every day. From the tray, those documents either go to recycling or into a file folder. Again, my goal is to only touch it once. Finally, I should note that I also have a similar filing system on my computer.
Okay, wake up!
I’ll forgive you if your soul escaped your body for the last eight paragraphs! The nitty gritty can get dry, but that’s kind of the point, isn’t it? I resisted the dry for years and the result was emotional chaos and suffering. I felt alot of unnecessary pain as a tree planter until I learned to be radically efficient with my trade. The same holds true for me as a helping professional. My hope is that you figure out and use some of these systems a good deal sooner than I did.
Here’s my main point:
Your work, especially the tedious parts, need to become automated through systems.
Think about the things you do every day that require no willpower and cause no stress, and yet are objectively boring or tedious. Is brushing your teeth fun? No. Is it hard, though? Not at all. In fact, you don’t have to even think about it. You go upstairs to prepare for bed and pick up your toothbrush- that’s it.
You see, boring is a strong emotion. It is actually a form of anxiety that emerges when we less-than-consciously say to ourselves “My life is passing me by. I’m missing out on something better right now.” Similarly, feelings of tedium arise when we get frustrated with the complex requirements of something that offers very little immediate return in exchange for our efforts. Yet they have to be done (teeth and paperwork). Now when we were little kids, brushing our teeth was hard.
If you don’t remember, look at your kids- they do a pretty bad job when they’re first learning! Sometimes they even lie and tell us they’ve done it when they haven’t. Why? It’s tedious! When you’re little it takes alot of mental energy to carefully brush each tooth in a certain way. Eventually- I mean after years of practice- we come to peace with the fact that we must brush every day. Our muscles learn to be very efficient and we can do the deed without much thought and it stops being stressful. In fact, we start to even feel good when we clean our pearly whites- we like how it feels, tastes, and we are satisfied with the knowledge that our dental hygienist won’t lecture us.
This is all I mean when I speak of systems. They don’t even have to look the way I laid them out above. Once we have accepted their necessity, have practiced them (maybe for a few years or more), and they have become almost unconscious for us, they lose their malicious effect on our souls. If we persist we will find our paperwork zen.
What systems have you developed over the years that serve you? Let us know in the comments section below.
Be Counted with the World’s Wealthiest 1%
I often feel poor. Yes, “poor” can be a feeling. It is the sense that what we have just isn’t enough. It is that sad feeling we get when we realize we can’t afford organic everything or that we have to buy clothes for our kids based solely on price- not like the other moms who seem to have their kids constantly decked out in premium brands. I often feel poor when I’m driving through upscale Vancouver neighborhoods and I realize that I will likely never be able to afford one of those opulent palaces. The “poor” feeling is usually vague, but it’s there.
It is so easy to feel subtle resentment toward those who seem to have it all. I mean, isn’t that part of the reason the “We are the 99” protests have picked up steam over the past few years? Our world is definitely and unfairly divided into the “haves” and the “have-nots”.
But let me tell you a little secret. You are not in the 99%. You are in the 1%.
Yes, you, the mid-level social worker. You the kindergarten teacher. You the counsellor. So the secret to becoming a part of the world’s top 1% is merely recognizing that you’re already there. Isn’t that great? You made it! If you have a household income of more than $50,000 per year, you belong to the wealthiest 1% of the planet’s population. You are the elite. In fact, if your income is just $10,000 per year, you are in the top 10% of the world’s wealth. In other words, if you make just $835 per month, there are 6,570,000,000 people who are poorer than you in the world.
Now I don’t want to get all preachy. And as social worker I definitely don’t want to knock the “We are the 99” movement. I respect what they’re all about. What I know for sure is what I feed my brain matters- when I am enticed by the wealth of the 0.01%- the Bill Gates and Oprah Winfreys of the world- the result is envy, discontent and malaise. When I focus on the fact that I have won the existential lottery- that I have my health, a loving family, and the means to do most of what I want- I feel satisfaction, joy, and gratitude.
When I choose to claim that secret (on a daily basis), the rest tends to fall into place.